The second video short is the content from our first session, introducing Lewis and his radio talk series, as well as his ideals from his first two chapters of Mere Christianity found at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AcQ70cPYcB8. If you missed the sessions I encourage you to follow these links and listen to the body of our content. I also encourage you to read the first five chapters of Mere Christianity and answer the following questions either as a comment on this blog or to yourselves.
*In the video
Alister McGrath states the Lewis rationale that right is not something that
humans invent or arbitrate---it is already there. Can you think of more
examples which illustrate the differences between moral absolutes and social
conventions? Why do you think that some Christians are reluctant to use their
minds when it comes to faith?
*Briefly describe
someone who believes right and wrong are personal preferences. How do they
compare in their lives to someone who, like Lewis, claims that there is a real
standard for right and wrong. Is this contradictory? How do we as a church and
Christians address this difference? Is there a contradiction?
*What does Lewis
mean when he says that the hallway is not a place Christians should live? When
do Christians live in the hallway? What is different about entering the room?
*What do you think
is behind our sense of right and wrong? Have you ever felt God’s hand in this
regard?
The concept of "moral absolutes" as a reflection of a particular culture is something I understand. Lewis was speaking, no doubt, as a representative of 'Western culture, that which we have inherited from Western Civilization as it has developed over the centuries. I agree with Lewis, and I do believe there are certain moral absolutes which are inherent to those of us who share as our heritage the development of Western Civilization. The crunch comes when we ask if these moral absolutes survive the test of cross cultural examination. I ask a question (without knowing the answer) as an example of my point: were the Crusades an example of the application of moral absolutes, or cross cultural disconnect?
ReplyDeleteIn the 28th Chapter of Job there is this question, as expressed musically in a marvelous anthem by William Boyce, "But where shall wisdom be found? and where is the place of understanding?" The answer is: "God understandeth the way thereof, and he knoweth the place thereof." I take from Job that since we are not God our wisdom is necessarily limited, as is our understanding. Jim Hammond
Sorry, I forgot to add the link to the Boyce Anthem, "O Where Shall Wisdom Be Found":
Deletehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B3-tYJ9xKbg